plaintiffs' lawyers argued that Guangzhou has a lot of creek culverts connected to the water system map Water alone was insufficient evidence required by the court investigation.
re going scene investigation
this year at 17:40 on May 14, Li Shuk Fan bus ride starting from Qingyuan, a small bell similar with her boyfriend to join in the Tianhe Bus Station. Since that day a lot of flooding Cave near the toll station, causing traffic in the traffic jam. The night 8:30, Li Shuk Fan Tianhe Bus Station in relatively close distance of a bus stop after a small bell to make a telephone call, since you heard from.
Wu: gone ', I get a bamboo pole fishing in the next, but the water can not hurry fishing. I quickly ran across the street to see,Moncler Doudoune, across all factories, houses, school buildings, waterways can not find export.
judge Resolution:
time: the incident on 17:30-20:20
yesterday in the trial scene, the plaintiff applied three witnesses, three students were dead Zhang, witnesses named Ma and Wu security after the incident involved in the rescue, they fell into the water before and after an attempt to restore the site details.
the deceased's own responsibility
indictment plaintiff wrote: Tianhe District, Water as a river construction and the construction and management unit, for drainage system maintenance and management of defects, and Li Shuk Fan's drowning has a direct causal relationship, the council should bear liability. According to management defects cause damage to tort liability, damages the plaintiff material and spiritual losses, a total of 1.1332 million yuan.
Tianhe District, construction and Water Authority rejected the family's claims, there are reasons --- the council that its management and maintenance of the creek is an administrative act, should not bear civil liability. And the day in Guangzhou, the aftermath of the Deceased as an adult, should know in the heavy rain forced walk dangerous, but she still insisted on early and get off, and the drainage creek to stay on top of the concrete barrier, make it this behavior and exposure to risk which eventually leading to the accident. In summary, the defendant that it should not be the death of Li Shuk Fan liability.
her sudden departure, so that the couple still difficult to accept. Father Lee said: , and now want to go have not go up. Father Lee said: >
Li Shuk Fan's death, her parents will build and Tianhe District, Guangzhou Water court. Plaintiff's counsel, because of the accident site was built too low cement fence, night of the incident the water level of rivers and almost flush with the sidewalk, cement fence just above the surface less than 10 centimeters,Moncler, around and no warning signs, so not familiar with the road of the dead can not tell river and road boundaries, leading to the accident. Moreover, the defendant after the incident in the original installation of the concrete barrier on the iron fence can be proved that if the defendant can take sufficient protective measures as soon as possible, then, accidents can be avoided, so the fault of the defendant should bear the responsibility of its management.
yesterday's trial lasted throughout the morning,Doudoune Moncler Femme, several rounds of hand gestures was the case photographs, the judge seeing immediately said: to the court for the transfer of Yuen Kong Street Police Station, Tianhe District, on May 14 this year, days of street Jubei Bay in the vicinity of the source of the surveillance video, they believe, will be sufficient to confirm that Li Shuk Fan surveillance video from the construction and management of the defendant into the drainage channel the water.
event playback
named Ma: , I saw a woman fall into the creek where she was standing on the cement embankment on the creek behind her back tilt Yang in. I shouted 'save', but the water too fast, just Within a couple of seconds to see her when there is no creek next to the fence, there is no safety tips.
Wu, Yue King parking lot security, after the incident had tried to save.
Tianhe District, construction and Water respondent that the evidence submitted by the family and can not directly prove that Li Shuk Fan is from the days fall into the road drain source Jubei Bay, because, according to creek water, Tianhe District, Guangzhou map, if Li Shuk Fan Chung from Jubei involved, and do not float to the tangxia Bay (ie, where the body was found), can be seen from the drawings Jubei Bay is to the east, the water flow from north to south, tangxia Bay is west, the flow from west to east, the two river 2 km apart, and no cross-port, pass each other, the body was in tangxia Bay that means that the dead can not be drowning in Jubei Chung.
the following two days, Li Shuk Fan's family tracing and students through a variety of ways,Moncler Outlet, but has no sign of it. Meanwhile, witnesses said, had seen the night of the incident the day a young woman fell on the road gutter source, but I am not sure whether Li Shuk Fan. 3 days later, police recovered from the Bay Tianhe District Tangxia a female body, and ultimately proved to be missing Li Shuk Fan.
three witnesses to recall details of the scene before and after the deceased fell into the water, according to the dead students, said:
was on the ground water has not been a knee, can not see the road, I quickly warned passers-by do not close here soon, come and help other people, took of the plastic rope cordon around the scene when it was to copy two Zhang brand, write 'creek hazard, do not close'. 8:50, two police officers came to the scene to bring life buoy, immediately notify the firefighters to the scene to rescue, but the water impatient, has been heavy rain,Doudoune Moncler Pas Cher, to 3 am points are not saved to the people.
Zhang: , reaching the day when the traffic jams start Yuen Road, during which Li Shuk Fan is often the phone rings, she should call the same person (boyfriend), she said: 'Now traffic jams, cars move did not move' an hour later, car or stagnate, she heard from station to walk to the Milky Way about ten minutes, they asked me not to walk, the rain was getting smaller, I agreed, but no more than ten meters out, the rain suddenly big ground water urgent and deep water, I was feeling a little scared, just like she said 'it was back to the car, the car forward a bit, should soon arrival of' So we went back to car , this time about 20:20, but may since she was too impatient to return to the car is not firmly secured five minutes, she was alone in a person under the car, and I have been in the car until the car drove into the Milky Way terminal, arrival time is about 22:50. witnesses.
water sector:
Zhang, Li Shuk Fan deceased students, basing their car the day together.
walk her twice arrival will want to get off her boyfriend
learned that the deceased parent had requested the amount of compensation is 82 million yuan, the latest Bureau of Statistics on annual per capita disposable income of urban residents has increased, so they increase the amount of the claim in court to 113 million yuan.
much media attention, Tianhe District, the family sued the building and the Water Authority and claims 1.13 million yuan. Tianhe District Water Authority is that the female students themselves are at fault, the council is not responsible. Yesterday, at three different time periods witnesses appeared to testify in court, made before and after the trouble to restore the whole process. The judge decided to fix a day heavy with the parties going on the scene for investigation.
deceased father:
to seek justice for her daughter to be dead
Related articles： bombs do was arrested after the public security organs , the other five suspects took the opportunity to escape .
